The Genesis of Public Opinion in Modern Russia (the case of support for Perestroika)
https://doi.org/10.21453/2311-3065-2022-10-1-80-96
Abstract
The article is devoted to the problem of the reliability of the picture of Russian public opinion, which emerges from the polling data. A historical approach to this problem is proposed on the example of testing the generally accepted assumption about the initially high level of support for perestroika in Soviet society. The paper shows that the generally accepted assumption is based on three theses: (a) a particularly high level of support for perestroika at the initial stages; (b) the perception of the idea of perestroika by the population as meeting its needs; (c) the gradual decline in support for perestroika due to the difficulties encountered. The author dwells on each of them and demonstrates that they do not correspond to the available empirical data. The results of a comparative analysis show that (a) support for perestroika was not higher than the usual levels of approval of the Soviet leadership by the population; (b) the population did not associate their most actual expectations with perestroika; (c) the decline in support for perestroika did not occur in parallel with the fall in living standards, but simultaneously, after the weakening of Gorbachev’s power. By analogy with public support for Perestroika, we can conclude that the possible overestimation of the overall support for the political regime in modern Russia is a much less serious problem compared to the internal structure of this support, the distribution of the shares of those who express it declaratively and those who are ready to embody their political attitudes into real actions.
About the Author
N. S. Babich
Institute of Sociology of Federal Center of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences (FCTAS RAS)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
CandSc (Soc.), senior researcher,
117218, Moscow, Krzhizhanovskogo str., bldg. 24/35
References
1. Artyomov A.V. (2015). The Image of Perestroika in 1990: Contradictions of Perception (Based on Sociological Research). Bulletin of the South Ural State University. Series: social sciences and humanities. Chelyabinsk. Vol. 15. No. 2. P. 91-96 (In Rus.).
2. Bashkirova E.I., Kizichenko Y.V. (1989). The attitude of the Soviet and American peoples to domestic political problems. In: V.S. Korobeinikov (ed.) Values of mass consciousness in the USSR and the USA. Moscow: ISI AN USSR. P. 46-55 (In Rus.).
3. Bezborodov A., Eliseeva N., Shestakov V. (2011). Perestroika and the collapse of the USSR. 1985-1993. SPb.: Norma (In Rus.).
4. Bourdieu P. (1993). Sociology of politics (transl.). Moscow: Socio-Logos (In Rus.).
5. Doucette C. (2021). Glasnost in the mailroom: The soviet subject in Gorbachev’s perestroika, 1985–1988. Soviet and Post-Soviet Review. Vol. 48. No. 2. P. 171-188.
6. Finifter A. W., Mickiewicz E. (1992). Redefining the political system of the USSR: mass support for political change. American political science review. No. 4. P. 857-874.
7. Fitzpatrick S. (1996). How mice buried a cat. Show trials in rural areas of the USSR in 1937. The fate of the Russian peasantry (transl.). Moscow: RGGU. P. 387-413 (In Rus.).
8. Frye T., Gehlbach S., Marquardt K.L., Reuter O.J. (2017). Is Putin’s popularity real? Post-soviet affairs. No. 1. P. 1-15.
9. Gorbachev M.S. (2006). Understand Perestroika…: Why It Matters Now. Moscow: Alpina Business Books (In Rus.).
10. Gordin A.A., Gordina E.D. (2018). Sociological surveys in the Gorky region as a tool for studying the socio-political position of citizens during the years of perestroika. On the materials of the archives of the Nizhny Novgorod region. Bulletin of the archivist. No. 1. P. 135-145 (In Rus.).
11. Gorshkov M.K. (1988). Public opinion: history and modernity. Moscow: Politizdat.
12. Gorshkov M.K., Petukhov V.V. (2005). Perestroika through the eyes of Russians: 20 years later. In: V.B. Kuvaldin (ed.) Breakthrough to freedom: About perestroika twenty years later (critical analysis). Moscow: Alpina Business Books. P. 374-413 (In Rus.).
13. Grachev A.S. (2001). Gorbachev. M.: Vagrius (In Rus.).
14. Gudkov L.D., Dubin B.V., Zorkaya N.A. (2012). Russian parliamentary elections: electoral process under an authoritarian regime. Bulletin of Public Opinion. Data. Analysis. Discussions. No. 1. P. 5-31 (In Rus.).
15. Ivanov V.N. (2018). Sociology in the USSR. Notes of the Director of the Institute. M.: U Nikitskih vorot (In Rus.).
16. Kalinin K. (2016). The social desirability bias in autocrat’s electoral ratings: evidence from the 2012 Russian presidential elections. Journal of elections, public opinion and parties. No. 2. P. 191-211.
17. Kalinin K. (2018). Linking preference falsification and election fraud in electoral autocracies: the case of Russia. Political studies (Polis). No. 1. P. 81-99.
18. Kon I.S. (1988). Psychology of social inertia. Kommunist. No. 1. P. 64-75 (In Rus.).
19. Kotz D.M., Vir F. (2016). Russia’s path from Gorbachev to Putin: the death of the Soviet system and the new Russia. Moscow: URSS (In Rus.).
20. Koval T. (1997). Economic reform and public opinion. In: V. Mau, N. Glavatskaya (eds.) Five years of reforms. M.: IEP. P. 239-282 (In Rus.).
21. Levada Y.A. (1993). Soviet common man. M.: World Ocean (In Rus.).
22. Levinson A. (2019). Opinion polls as a special historical source for the study of the 1990s. Emergency reserve. Debate about politics and culture. No. 3. P. 103-106 (In Rus.).
23. Lidzhi-Goryaeva S.E. (1989). Problems of development of socio-political activity of workers in the conditions of perestroika. In: I.E. Namsinov (ed.) Socialist way of life and perestroika (based on the materials of the Kalmyk ASSR). Elista. P. 23-44 (In Rus.).
24. Ligachev E.K. (2010). Who betrayed the USSR? M.: Algorithm (In Rus.).
25. Lukyanov A.I. (1999). In the whirlpool of Russian unrest. Reflections, dialogues, documents. M.: Book and business (In Rus.).
26. Marinov V.A. (1990). Formation of new political thinking and stereotypes of the past (according to the results of research for the Time magazine). In: V.N. Ivanova (ed.) Problems of the formation of new thinking. M.: ISI AN USSR. P. 22-45 (In Rus.).
27. Marples D.R. (2013). The collapse of the Soviet Union: 1985-1991. London: Routledge.
28. Medvedev R.A. (2006). How Perestroika Started. M.: Human rights (In Rus.).
29. Melville A.Y. (2017). Neoconservative consensus in Russia? Key components, sustainability factors, erosion potential. Politiya. No. 1. P. 29-45 (In Rus.).
30. Rogov K. (2017). Political reaction in Russia and «party groups» in Russian society. Russian politics & law. No. 2. P. 77-114.
31. Shlapentokh V. (1990). Public opinion in Gorbachev's USSR: Consensus and polarization. Media, culture & society. No. 2. P. 153-174.
32. Shubin A.V. (2007). The paradoxes of perestroika. Lost chance of the USSR. M.: Veche (In Rus.).
33. Toshchenko J.T., ed. (1990). Political consciousness and its role in the restructuring and renewal of social relations. M.: AON under the Central Committee of the CPSU (In Rus.).
34. Toshchenko J.T., Shchegortsova V.A., Yakovlev A.I., eds. (1988). Political consciousness of workers in the conditions of perestroika and acceleration of socio-economic development. M.: AON under the Central Committee of the CPSU (In Rus.).
35. Toshchenko Z.T. (1990). State and contradictions of public consciousness by the end of 1988. In: V.A. Yadov (ed.) Sociology of perestroika. M.: Nauka. P. 81-96 (In Rus.).
36. Uledov A.K. (1990). Spiritual renewal of society. M.: Mysl (In Rus.).
37. Vasilyeva E.P., Kinsbursky A.V., Koklyagina L.A., Semenova V.V., Topalov M.N., Chuprov V.I. (1987). The attitude of students to the social sciences. Sociological Studies. No. 4. P. 20-24 (In Rus.).
38. Zaslavskaya T.I. (1991). Socialism, Perestroika and Public Opinion. Sociological Studies. No. 8. P. 3-21 (In Rus.).
39. Zaslavskaya T.I. (2002). Societal transformation of Russian society: an activity-structural concept. M.: Delo (In Rus.).
40. Zdravomyslova O.M. (2005). Perestroika and the “Gorbachev factor” in the public opinion of the West and the USSR, 1985-1991. In: V.B. Kuvaldin (ed.) Breakthrough to freedom: About perestroika twenty years later (critical analysis). M.: Alpina Business Books. P. 354-373 (In Rus.).
41. Zemtsov I. (1989). Reality and facets of perestroika. London: Overseas (In Rus.). Zlobin N.V. (1989). Ways of perestroika: experience and modernity. M.: Higher school (In Rus.).
Review
For citations:
Babich N.S. The Genesis of Public Opinion in Modern Russia (the case of support for Perestroika). Communicology. 2022;10(1):80-96. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.21453/2311-3065-2022-10-1-80-96
Views:
313
Email this article 
